deviant art

Deviant Login Shop  Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
[x]
more ▶

Featured in Groups:

Details

April 15, 2009
Link
Thumb

Statistics

Comments: 10
Favourites: 0
Views: 29 (0 today)
[x]
Hi at all! :wave:

As I wrote in my last journal entry, one of my pictures was used and altered by :iconsironabennet:
As she claimed it her own I reported the deviation to DA and they put the deviation down immediately.

I also wrote a note to her explaining my point:

"OK, for me this is bad for 2 reasons:

1) You traced my artwork (what would be OK if you'd have asked me first ar at least admitted that you traced it with a link in the description) and you claim YOU drew it in your description!
2) You stole MY character, changed it only slightly and use it in YOUR webcomic (again without asking for permission first)!

I had to deal with art thieves before but none of them was that barefaced. I'm really disappointed.
This character is not only a made up gargoyle - it is MY fursona, it is ME! As my fursona looks a little different now, I would have agreed to let you use the design for your character, if you had ASKED ME. But you did not. I'm really pissed right now. Honestly I feel like telling you to remove this character from your webcomic.
... But I'm not that much of an asshole. Please write me a note if you want to keep using this character design. I'm sure we will find a solution.

However, as you claimed my artwork as yours, I had to report this deviation as copyright infrigment. If you use other artist's pictures as base again please ask for permission first and post a link to the original artwork in the description!"


She was VERY VERY cooperative. I'm really happy about that!
Most "art thieves" keep arguing and fighting and flaming the original artist (I do know that she wrote an angry journal about being blamed for art theft but I'm sure this was just out of affect - what I can somehow understand).
She instead honestly apologized for what happened. I'm sure that what she did was not out of bad intentions. She is not a bad person. She is just young and maybe didn't know that what she was doing is considered art theft.

To resolve the matter I asked her to
:bulletgreen: add the information to her webpage that the design is based on my character (so people will know, that this is not my alter ego but a gargoyle who looks like it)
:bulletgreen: add a little text to the pictures she took/traced/redrew from other artists naming the original artist (like "Original artwork by (artist), altered by me" )   and
:bulletgreen: ask the original artists for permission first before using a picture as a base again and give a link to the original artwork in the picture description here on DA


She agreed, added a comment about the original artists to her webcomic page [link] and promised to never do anything like that again. She learned from what happened and will do better in the future! That's a really great outcome!

:iconsironabennet: Thank you very much for being that understanding and cooperative! I do not hold any grudge against you. Mistakes are alright, if people learn from them in the end. I wish you good luck with your webcomic and with your growth as an artist!

Greetings
Neomae
  • Mood: Caring
  • Listening to: I thought I lost you
  • Watching: Bolt
Add a Comment:
 
:iconmyuutsucmce:
Good news, she learned!
Reply
:iconstarscream64:
Funny. I got a heads up from a fellow garg artist that that SAME user had also used some of my own artwork. But by the time I checked it had been taken down. Well, so long as a lesson was learned here, and it was quickly removed, aparently.
Reply
:iconlexgoyle:
~LexGoyle Apr 15, 2009  Student Digital Artist
Well what a great outcome out of a potentially /BAD/ situation. Well done on resolving the matter ^_^
Reply
:iconhidden-traveler:
Then i take it you haven't read her latest journal entry?

"Okay, so I logged on Deviant Art, was in a happy mood. Then I read that people are saying my artwork is theres. This is soo annoying!! I mean, everyone just get off my back with the whole "Oh, this work is not yours, raddy radda". People, I AM a normal human being, so stop hounding me!

Sorry about this outburst, I just had to let it out. And trust me, if it wasn't for my persistant friends on MSN, this would be muuuuuuuch longer.

Ta ta"
Reply
:iconepantiras:
*Epantiras Apr 15, 2009  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Ah, good to see the problem has been resolved as civilized people should do ;-)
Reply
:icontumiaus:
Very nice!
Reply
:iconcaptainthomas:
It's nice to see she was willing to listen to you =)
Reply
:iconvegi-chan:
Ich habe echt Hochachtung vor dir, dass du es so erwachsen und mit Fassung durchgezogen hast.
Das ist bewundernswert :)
Reply
:iconbobszy:
Good deal. :)
Reply
Add a Comment: